Gran Torino (2008): Movie Review

This review is a spoiler, so stop here if you plan to watch it and you don’t want to know the ending.  And by the way, I save a few Atheist specific comments to the end.
gran-torinoThe movie opens at the funeral of Walt Kowalski’s wife.  Walt, a cantankerous, bitter Korean War vet now lives alone in a neighborhood with very few fine White folks like himself.  His bitterness has alienated him from his neighborhood and from his own family.  The only beauty remaining in his world is his own troll embellished neurotically manicured lawn.  Walt’s only remaining past-time after fixin’ up the house is to sit on his porch and drink 8 cans of beer out of a cooler bad mouthing everything his sees.

But the movie is full of redemption when we see the soft-side of this old fart come out as a hero.  I love movies that make folks complex and shows people changing their ways.   My Dad had a lot of Walt’s traits — lots of guys did from that era (my Dad served in WWII).  Like Walt, he had a bigoted word for every race and religion, but like Walt he mingled well enough with all of them and was actually a fine citizen.  The movie slowly shows us Walt’s strong side which blossoms into a savior in the end.  To draw out and nourish Walt’s inner hero we get the help of several characters.  First his dead wife’s wish for her dear stubborn husband’s salvation are brought to Walt’s door by a naive but diligent priest.  Walt shoos away the priest, but the door has been cracked and it isthe words of a sassy, bright, and kind Hmong girl next door which opens the door of Walt’s heart.  Then our renewed Hero helps straighten the life of the trampled Hmong young boy next door.  Everyone redeems everyone else — it is wonderful.  Seriously, I am a sap, I love this stuff.

OK, I didn’t think the acting was the best, but again, I will sacrifice acting for a sappy story line. So, that said, I did want to make a few Atheist specific observations.
Walt finds out he has fatal lung cancer, but no one else knows — shhhhh !  He has befriended the Hmong neighbors by “helping” them ward of an Asian gang who is recruiting their son to a life of callous sin.  Yet Walt’s help is in the form of violence which only leads to more violence (of course).  And so with Clint Eastwood as Walt, we expect guns to go a blazin’.  But Walt has grown very fond of his Hmong neighbors, he was a hero in the Korean War and is very smart and good at fixing things.  Sure he punches his hand through a few things in anger (hell, he is man), but then he sits down and thinks and comes up with a plan.

He goes to the gang-house by himself, taunts the no-good hoodlums until they all shower him with bullets while the neighborhood watches Walt blasted down to sprawl as an sacrificial ornament on the neighborhood sidewalk.  The gang is hauled off to prison and Dead-Walt saves the lives of the Hmong family by sacrificing his own.

But wait, it ain’t too bad, Walt had Cancer anyway, remember !  This is just like Tommy Lee Jones in another of Eastwood’s films “Space Cowboys” where Jones sacrifices himself to die alone on the moon to save Earth from a nuclear disaster.   The sacrifices are nobel, but hell, we are happy for them because going out with a flame is far better than withering with cancer.  And in a funny way, these Jesus-figures illustrate how really toned down Jesus’ sacrifice really was too.

Jesus was supposedly 100% man and 100% god.  So he knows when he dies he goes back to being a god in heaven — absolute surety (unlike us pathetic, fear-ridden humans who only have the meagerest of hope in life-after-death).  Jesus knows 100% that when he dies, he is leaving future suffering of being a lowly human and runs right back to his homemade paradise.  Wow, some sacrifice.  OK, sure, it is great to help others on the way out, but the director (God, in this case) saves us from shedding too many tears for Jesus, we are just happy for ourselves — the saved.  But come on, why not have a young, family-man Walt with a long life in-front of him sacrifice himself for the Hmong family.  Well, because we’d walk away from that movie real sad and hating the Hmong gang and have all sorts of nasty feelings.
Gran Torino
The movie, instead, left me with good feelings.  Hell, I even liked the priest in this movie — his sincerity and open mindedness were inspiring.  Ooops, are Atheists allowed to like redemptions, priests and forgiveness.  Hell yes !  So if you want a movie to make you feel good, give it a peak.  But if you are a half-way intelligent movie critic (which thank Krishna, I am not), you might give this one a pass.


Filed under Philosophy & Religion

11 responses to “Gran Torino (2008): Movie Review

  1. Nice review of a fairly complex film. It raises some interesting questions about loyalty, race relations, and faith.

    Regarding Jesus? I wonder, historically-speaking, just how much he really believed about his own part in the cosmic redemptive plan, and how much the subsequent writers of the gospels imparted upon him.

    Great post.

  2. @ tysdaddy — thanx, that was the first movie review I ever penned out.
    Agreed, historically speaking I have a low Christiology seeing Jesus as an unexpectant Messiah — he did not think of himself as such. Instead, he thought the “son of man” was coming to usher the kindgdom in physically in his own life time and not only is he surprised when he doesn’t come but also when he is called off and executed. Now I could be wrong on a lot of that — being ancient re-written story telling and all.

  3. There is something I always love about the casual or nominal racist turned warm hearted minority lover. I went to a zero-minority high school, literally, zero minorities in about 1000 students over the 6 years I was there. I remember seeing a guy I knew at a 5-year reunion party waxing poetic (and drunkenly) about about his kids. The proud dad pulled out photos from his wallet to show me his two adopted African American kids. I was amazed and moved, not that I knew him to be a racist, but essentially most people there would have spoken the way you describe your father. You never know what lies underneath.

  4. I enjoyed the movie. It’s a feel-good sort of film with a social message behind it: not all immigrants turn out bad, but the environment and lack of opportunities can lure kids to the wrong path.

    It also speaks of how difficult the problem is to tackle.

    I thought the movie offered enough food for thought independently of the savior theme.

  5. Has anyone seen the movie Grand Canyon? The main character is not sacrificed at the end, but sounds like maybe some similar themes. I liked that movie a lot and am curious if others consider it good.

  6. @ Lorena — absolutely, I agree. And not all damn Pollacks are bad to the core. I can testify — my wife is Polish and I have found one or two ripe spots. But us Welshmen are picky !

    @ ATTR — I will add it to my NetFlix list – thanx

  7. Cally

    I thought the writer would be considered God, not the director….

    Interesting where this movies comes from:

  8. Temaskian

    Totally enjoyed the movie. But then I enjoy all Clint Eastwood movies. Recently enjoyed some of his old ones too, like A Few Dollars More, A Fistful of Dollars, The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.

    For this movie, particularly enjoyed the way he related to the preacher, and how their relationship changed.

  9. i reviewed this movie a while back, and we land in very similar places:

    excellent review, i like yours better. i also enjoy the communal aspect of salvation “everyone saves everyone else.” this is the Good News i read in the Gospels (and a little bit in Paul, like 1 Cor, but not Romans, it’s all christ there). so i really jive with this and would point you to NT Wright’s book, even though i may have given you this link before:

    i’m really excited to read what you have to write. keep ’em come’n!

  10. Pingback: A Perfect World (1993) « I Remember Everything

Please share your opinions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s