Is the Tanakh “Great Literature”?

Presently, my poll shows more than 60% of my readers have read all of the Tanakh (AKA: “The Jewish Bible: — also derogatorily called the “Old” Testament by Christians).  Some people would call “The Bible” great literature. But as my Tanakh post illustrates, “the Bible” is really a little library of many books which we can’t judge as a whole. Discussing “the Bible” as if it were just one book is actually partially buying into the fundamentalist believer’s notion of a homogenized, spirit-guided book.

Questions for readers:

  • If you think the Tanakh qualifies as great literature, which book(s) do you think qualify as great literature?
  • Which books, or parts of books, do you think should be required reading for kid before college?
  • Which do you think should be required for liberal arts students who are trying to get a “well-rounded education”?
  • What other world-religion texts do you think should be required?
  • Which secular authors do you think should be required?
  • If not required in school, which to you recommend reading casually?
  • Do you think reading the Tanakh is benefitial even without supplementary reading?

Let’s hear it!  (Yes, NT stuff is coming later)



Filed under Philosophy & Religion

2 responses to “Is the Tanakh “Great Literature”?

  1. Earnest

    I think Genesis and Exodus qualify as at least classic literature, if not great literature. There is not much published from that time period to compare them to.

    But I can also say that it is the old-sounding fragments that I think are great. it is well known that Genesis seems to start twice. As a concretion of various authors Genesis seems to me to be a bit disjointed.

  2. I’ll try be concise:

    1. Great literature: Samuel, parts of Job & Ecclesiastes, some fairly small excerpts from the later prophets (Isaiah..Malachi)
    2. Required reading for kids: Genesis, Exodus, some small selections from Leviticus..Kings
    3. Well rounded education: everything with the possible exception of Chronicles, Ruth, half of Psalms+Proverbs
    4. Other world religion texts: bits from rabbinic sources, NT, Church fathers, Koran and hadith, some Buddhist scriptures, Chuang Tzu, Analects etc — depending on how much you can squeeze in!
    5/6. Other secular authors+casual reading: very hard to come up with a list off the top of my head, especially since it needs a whole theory of education to go with it (eg. whether it’s even worthwhile having required readings)
    7. Is reading Tanakh beneficial — definitely! But to a point, then you get into diminishing returns. There is benefit in knowing the narrative parts as well as the laws and basic worldviews. But by the time you’ve read a handful of Psalms, for instance, reading up to the full 150 might not give much.

Please share your opinions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s