Bloggers are people too

There is a famous Buddhist story (copied below) which illustrates that in every household there is suffering. It is foolish to assume that others are not having difficulties of some sort in their lives. And as I read the harsh words of some commentors on other sites, I wonder if they even imagine that the person they are assaulting may be suffering illness, death, separation, depression, turmoil, financial insecurity, anxiety or even worse in their personal life. Do brutal commentors forget that the world does not evolve around their emotions.

Sometimes I am also more harsh in my comments than I wish I were. I forget that there is a real person which will be receiving my black-and-white typed messages. I forget that they may have a world where they are suffering. I forget to be courteous and thoughtful.

So let’s take a second and remember that the people we are arguing with have a personal life that may have some rough spots right now. Let’s strive to be courteous, thoughtful and not destructive. We can be firm and straightforward and still be civil.

Click the “continue reading” if you wish to read the Buddhist story.

From the Dhammapad Commentary (Part IV)

[A woman’s young son died and she grieved deeply.  But she heard of a great Buddhist teacher who she hoped could possibly bring the son back to life–“cure her son”.]  So she went to the Teacher, paid obeisance to him, stood at his side, and asked him, “Venerable sir, is it true, as men say, that you know how to cure my child?” – “Yes, I know that.” – “What shall I get?” – “A pinch of white mustard seed.” – “I will get that, venerable sir. But in whose house shall I get it?” – “In whose house neither son nor daughter nor any other has yet died.” – “Very well, venerable sir,” said she, and paid obeisance to him.

Then she placed the dead child on her hip, entered the village, stopped at the door of the very first house, and asked, “Have you here any white mustard seed? They say it will cure my child.” – “Yes.” – “Well then, give it to me.” They brought some grains of white mustard seed and gave them to her. She asked, “Friends, in the house where you dwell has son or daughter yet died?” – “What are you saying, woman? As for the living they are few; only the dead are many.” – “Well then, take back your mustard seed; that is no medicine for my child.” So saying, she gave back the mustard seed.

After this manner, going from house to house, she plied her quest. There was not a single house where she found the mustard seed she sought; and when the evening came, she thought, “Ah! It’s a heavy task I took upon myself. I thought that I alone had lost a child, but in every village the dead are more in number than the living.” While she reflected thus her heart, which until then was soft with mother’s love, became firm. She took the child and discarded him in the forest. Then she went to the Teacher, paid homage to him, and stood to one side.

Said the Teacher, “Did you get the pinch of mustard seed?” – “No, I did not, venerable sir. In every village the dead are more in number than the living.” Said the Teacher, “You imagined vainly that you alone had lost a child. But all living beings are subject to an unchanging law, and it is this: The Prince of Death, like a raging torrent, sweeps away into the sea of ruin all living beings, but still their longings are unfulfilled.” And instructing her in the Dhamma, he pronounced the following stanza:

In flocks and children finding delight
With a mind clinging – just such a man
Death seizes and carries away,
As a great flood a sleeping village.

As the Teacher uttered the last part of the stanza, Kisa Gotami was established in the fruit of stream-entry [awakening]. Likewise did many others also obtain the fruit of stream-entry, and the fruits of the second and third paths. Kisa Gotami requested the Teacher to let her go forth; accordingly he sent her to the Order of Nuns and directed that they let her go forth. Afterwards she obtained acceptance as a nun and came to be known as the nun Kisa Gotami.


Filed under Blogging

11 responses to “Bloggers are people too

  1. Note to readers: If you think you have seen the post before, you have. I separated it from the post on “Morning Greetings” because I think the point in this post needs to stand alone. And I added a nice Buddhist parable for flavor.

  2. TWF

    I’m guilty too of being more harsh than I should be, and I am definitely trying to put an end to that kind of behavior from myself.

    My Buddhist friend has relayed that same basic story to me, but with a few variations as I remember:
    – there was no cure ingredient
    – she just had to find a house that had not lost a loved one, not specifically a child
    – she found enlightenment herself before she completed searching her whole village, and was not mentioned to go back to the teacher.

  3. @ TWF:
    Actually, as I have written, you and David Chapman are two of my role models of patient, thoughtful commentors on your own blogs and here.

    Concerning those apocryphal versions you heard — you can bet which ever “Buddhists” told you those satan-influenced version, that they will reborn as worms!
    Or, maybe I had better check my source to avoid eating dirt in the next life. Damn, why is it so tough to get our beliefs are right?
    Did they offer a link in their story, huh?

  4. @ TWF:
    Actually, I had a different version too: it was the Buddha, the message was just simple and no one got enlightened. And she was getting “one grain of rice” from each house.

    But when I did this post, I thought it would be nice to find the source or see if there even was a source. That is all I could find — it took me 20 minutes of looking — “rice” did not help the search. 🙂

    We can see how stories change when passed on orally — and I probably only heard it 10 years ago. But the gist of the moral is the same — minus the idealism.

  5. I am seldom harsh outright in my comments, it is usually when responding to harshness that I become less kind. I can become even less kind when defending others. I would prefer to be kind at all times, but sometimes my ego feels the need to knock someone down a peg.

  6. @ Mike,
    Yeah, I am not for 100% sweetness, and firmness is definitely therapeutic for some. But unnecessary harshness, as you know, abounds – esp. in Atheist-Theist dialogues. The moments you mention are certainly my temptations too.

  7. I’ve found that a quiet, firm voice can be much more effective than one that is loud.

  8. Good post. I definitely find myself more harsh than I would like on occasion (especially back when I first started blogging). It is a good idea to remember you are talking to a real person.

  9. @ Hausdorff: Yeah, I think bloggers change over time — especially if they have their own blogs. Thanx for stopping in.

  10. Earnest

    Sometimes I think as the intensity of my religiosity has eroded my real and virtual speech has become more moderate.

  11. @ Earnest, This sounds like a healthy thing !

Please share your opinions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s