Jehovah Witness Exposé

truth_be_toldLast week I went to a screening of an exposé on the Jehovah Witnesses called “Truth be Told”. The film is a montage of interviews with several ex-JWs who discuss their childhood indoctrinations, their deprivations from holidays, their witnessing habits, the insular back-biting community and the difficulty leaving their religion.

Here is  a 30 minute condensed version of the film and here is the wikipedia article with more links.

The film did not discuss prayer, god or doctrines (nothing on blood transfusions, for instance). Instead it was about the escapees’ inner turmoil. It was a bit long for me but interesting.  What made my outing interesting was the discussion afterwards.

The theater had about 60 people, 2/3 of whom were former JWs. The only JWs I had known until then were patients — we had a surgeon in our group who did surgeries without transfusions for JWs. So listening to these JWs describe their indoctrinations and difficulty leaving their faith was fascinating.

I asked one question of the producer: “Your film seems to show problems in many religions, not just JWs.  In your experience, what percentage of JWs leave to become believers in another faith?”  He thought it was 10% and several ex-JWs jumped in agreeing with him saying, once you see through the bullshit, it is hard to get tricked again.  But I do know many join other Christian groups.  Here is a 7 minute youtube, of one such woman.  One ex-JW said that JWs so stress that there can only be ONE truth, so for her, saying “No” to the Witnesses made it impossible to join yet another truth monopoly.

As I listened to these ex-believers give their anti-testimonies, I walked away with one interesting insight: I had a lot in common with many of these folks. I realized that those who have left an enthusiastic faith often share many attitudes – no matter what religion or fanatic group they left. I was surprised to see I had so much in common with EX-JWs.  If you’ve never been part of a fanatic group, you don’t know what you are missing! 🙂

Question for readers:  Have you ever felt commonality with other ex-believers of a completely different group?



Filed under Philosophy & Religion

3 responses to “Jehovah Witness Exposé

  1. I watched the condensed version and I do feel a comradery with anyone who has left any truth monopoly.

  2. Hm… interesting. I’ll definitely watch the condensed version. But I’m afraid I can’t answer your question as I’ve never belonged to any “truth monopoly” group. The only thing that has happened to me is that, at some point, I realized how bad religion can be. (Thanks be to Texas and my years there. Before that, my only negative feeling about religion had been the fact that various Christian churches in several countries around the world were always on the side of totalitarian regimes whenever those existed. E.g., in Greece in the 60s, or in Italy during WWII. Interestingly, since I’ve moved to Sweden, I started revising and enlarging the scope of “truth monopolies” and “religion-like” regimes.)

    An anecdote about JWs (true story). The father of a student of mine used to receive JWs at home frequently. Every time, he would invite them in, offer them tea, and chat with them. After several such visits, over the course of months, one of the smartly dressed JWs asked his host: “We’ve been coming to you so many times, you’ve been so kind and hospitable to us, but you haven’t shown any signs that you’d like to join us yet.” His reply was: “All these times, I was trying to deconvert you!” They never came back.

  3. @ Alice: In a coming post, I also hope to show that the opposite is probably also true with you. Hope to hear from you there.

    @ Takis: Fun story — thanx.

Please share your opinions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s