Iraq: More than Religion

Iraq_landHuge numbers of Americans barely know where Iraq is, yet alone know anything about her. And of those who do, most have a simple impression of the conflict in Iraq. Their media-fed view is that an evil jihadi militia is gruesomely sweeping through Iraq turning the country to convert Iran into an Islamist oppressive state. More sophisticated Americans supplement this view by actually knowing the two words “Shiite” and “Sunni” and thinking that the problems has something to do with a centuries-old conflict between these two sects. Some even know a bit of the Islamic history behind these two sects. But according to this excellent NYbooks post, the Iraq conflict is not fundamentally about a conflict between Islamic sects, but is “mostly about politics: access to government revenue and services, a say in decision-making, and a modicum of social justice.”

It is this level of analysis that I also push for when we study religion in general. Sure, looking at theological arguing points may seem important, but to truly understand religion is to see how doctrines serve politics, relationships, decision-making, and the human psyche. Sure, many believers may think that real religion is about metaphysical truth propositions, but they too are misunderstanding the large part of how such ideas work.

So, be suspect of the media when they dumb down events. Be suspect of simple labels as they tempt you to understand a country, a religion, a person or even yourself. The under workings of reality are much more interesting that the easy-to-remember labels.

This post is not necessarily meant to discuss Iraq, anyone’s lack of understanding, Islam or any such thing.  There is too much to understand in this world, ignorance is inevitable. Instead, I am merely pointing out how easily we buy into simple, convenient explanations — and worse yet, how we take our own superficial understandings seriously.




Filed under Philosophy & Religion

3 responses to “Iraq: More than Religion

  1. Earnest

    Great link Sabio. And I agree that one often has to dig through layers to find truth in both belief system analysis and Iraqi current events.

  2. A few months back, there was a study done: the opinion that we should have troops in the Ukraine was directly linked to a lack of knowledge of where the Ukraine was. (Survey takers were asked to point it out on an unlabeled map. There was a very strong correlation between how far they put the pins from the actual location and how strongly they felt there should be troops there.)

    I have a suspicion that a similar condition holds true for Iraq — although since we’ve had the military over there twice now in the last 25 years, the map location is probably a bit better-known.

  3. @ Earnest: Thanx. Glad you enjoyed the link.

    @ The Vicar:
    Fascinating. I wonder if the reason for this occurrence is that location on map was a proxy for general knowledge. Thus not knowing the map means not knowing much and thus more vulnerable to simple, generic media.
    I found a Washington Post article discussing the study:

Please share your opinions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s