Ironic Prejudice: How do Polish dogs bark?

dog barkI work for a large company, and float around at various clinics, often working with people I have never met. Two weeks ago, after being with the company for already a year, I had my first feedback session from an Area Director (AD),  who had never yet met me. Those meetings (I’ve had dozens of them over my career) are a time to tell the employee any complaints or areas of needed improvement.

The AD hesitantly shared a complaint from some unnamed employee who accused me of being prejudice. The day of the incident I was working with a new physician who was a young polish woman with a heavy accent. The offense, my AD told me, was that I asked the physician, “How do Polish dogs bark?

On hearing this, I laughed. The AD was surprised and said, “You see, you have to be careful what you say to people and how you react.” To which I replied, “You mean because it is giving away my prejudice that she is a dumb female foreigner, right?”

The AD looked at me startled by my apparent blunt bigotry. Then I said, “Look, you don’t know my background at all, so here it is ….” (here is my language background, if don’t know). After sharing my cultural experiences, the AD was visibly much more relaxed. Then I told her that every language uses different words to describe the sounds that animals make, they are very different from language to language. For instance, in English dogs say “woof, woof”, in Polish they say “hau hau”, in Japanese they say “wan wan” and in Hindi they say “bho bho”.

The sounds animals make is not common sense? These sounds are called onomatopoeias — for a fantastic list of comparative sounds between languages, see this wiki page.

After educating my AD she apologized for this horrific misunderstanding. Then I pointed out a worse irony: For though the polish doctor and I had a great time with the discussion (both of us having lived long times as foreigners), the listeners themselves (Americans who only speak one language) probably had a hidden prejudice which I lacked, and they themselves probably thought that the poor woman doctor was dumb because she spoke with an accent, and thus they thought I was picking on her. Arghhhh!



Filed under Philosophy & Religion

6 responses to “Ironic Prejudice: How do Polish dogs bark?

  1. rautakyy

    Dogs say “hau hau” also in Finnish, wich is curious, because Finnish is not at all related to Polish. There is the Baltic sea in between our two nations, separating, but also connecting. And of course, also some of the Baltic languages…

  2. In Greek, dogs say ΓΑΒ ΓΑΒ. Even the most famous of Greek dogs, Loukanikos (his obituary link from Wall Street Journal), spoke thus.

    Frogs still say ΒΡΕΚΕΚEΞ ΚΟAΞ ΚΟAΞ and they’ve been saying the same thing for at least 2500 years.

    Greek is a rather stable language (or whatever you call a language which doesn’t change much with time) and even Greek animals comply with this.

  3. R Vogel

    This is great! The first time I learned dogs bark differently in different language was on a high school missionary trip to Mexico. (they said Gua, Gua!)

    This actually get me thinking about religion, and in particular how I think of religions as a kind of language to speak about things like meaning, morality, the divine (if that’s your bag). Which then makes me think a wonderful name for a book in comparative religions would be ‘How does G*d bark in Polish?’

  4. associatedluke

    Oh the ironies of PC.

    Languages I have a passing familiarity with, the dogs say “wuff, wuff; wau, wau” (German) “guau-guau; gua, gua; jau, jau” (Spanish, depending on the region) and “vov, vuf” (Danish). Good things to think about. I’m going to ask this “provocative” question more.

  5. @ rautakyy,
    Maybe Finns got their first dogs from Poland after swimming across the Baltic sea. 😉

    Great story about that dog. If only Greek economics were as stable as here language.

    R Vogel,
    I, on the other hand, think people look at meaning, morality, mortality and wonder and some bark “God”, “Allah”, “Krishna”, “Zeus”, and more. But some don’t bark but just look.

    My next dogs are going to be the non-barking type. Way too noisey.

    PC Irony — that is indeed the point!

Please share your opinions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s